Rentals in Paradise Inc

4.9(113 reviews on Google)

Airbnb Property Management listing in Marathon, FL

About Rentals in Paradise Inc

Katie Carrillo owns Rentals in Paradise and manages its portfolio of more than 40 Marathon and Key Colony Beach properties herself, many on the water with private pools, boat docks, ocean access and sunset views. She describes vacation rental management for owners that includes guest communication, property oversight, and coordinating maintenance, vendors and inspections. The company has been in business for over a decade and features homes such as Island Paradise, Peace of Paradise and Indigo Palace. Rated 4.9 from 113 Google reviews, 110 of them five stars. Guests choose between Marathon and Key Colony Beach, and listings include condos and houses with ocean access, canal frontage and fish cleaning stations. Other homes named include Sea Renity, Keys Turtle House and Reel Paradise. The phone number is 1-305-879-2543.

What reviewers mention: boat friendly (8), comfortable beds (5), quick responses (5), quietness (5), canal access (4), ocean access (3), hot tub (3), kayaks (2), manatee sightings (2), clean house (2)

Services and details

  • Short-term rental management

    Yes
  • Maintenance and repairs

    Yes

No information yet on full-service management, co-hosting, dynamic pricing, 24/7 guest support, cleaning and turnover, listing setup and photography, listed on multiple platforms, licensing and tax compliance, owner portal and reporting, fee stated on website, also manages long-term rentals, design and furnishing. The website did not say; call and ask.

Contact

Listing compiled from public sources on 2026-10-14. Report a correction or request removal. Back to Airbnb property management companies in Marathon.