About First Choice Florida Vacation Rentals
First Choice Florida Vacation Rentals has been local to St. Augustine since 1998 and manages houses and condos from Vilano Beach to Summer Haven, with more than 70 properties including beach houses, oceanfront condos, pet-friendly homes and homes with pools. Guests book directly with no booking fees and get 24-hour phone support from a St. Augustine-based team that has worked together for decades. Property owners are invited to have the company manage their vacation rental, with a focus on maximizing bookings. The office on A1A Beach Boulevard is open weekdays from 9 to 5. Rated 4 from 84 Google reviews, 57 of them five stars and 16 one star. Nightly rates in the listings start around $110 for a two bedroom cottage sleeping four, and the menu sorts rentals into house, condo, pet friendly, swimming pool, oceanfront and beach choices. Contact is by phone at 904-429-7373 or by email.
Services and details
Short-term rental management
Yes24/7 guest support
Yes
No information yet on full-service management, co-hosting, dynamic pricing, cleaning and turnover, maintenance and repairs, listing setup and photography, listed on multiple platforms, licensing and tax compliance, owner portal and reporting, fee stated on website, also manages long-term rentals, design and furnishing. The website did not say; call and ask.
Contact
- (904) 429-7373
- 1017 A1A Beach Blvd, St Augustine Beach, FL 32080
- Website
- View on Google Maps
Listing compiled from public sources on 2026-10-14. Report a correction or request removal. Back to Airbnb property management companies in St Augustine Beach.